Ahmadiyya BooksAhmadiyya Books

The Eternal Cycle-Why Only God-Conscious Leadership Endures

Examining why history repeats itself in leadership and how only God-fearing, competent leaders who fear divine accountability can break the endless cycle of political disappointment

Dr. Nasim Rehmatullah - Naib Amir USA & Chairman Markazi Al Islam Team

Published: October 23, 2025

The Eternal Cycle-Why Only God-Conscious Leadership Endures

History repeats itself with stunning regularity. Every generation believes it has discovered new truths, yet we find ourselves caught in ancient patterns, electing leaders who promise transformation, only to disappoint us with their excesses. We swing from one extreme to another, from socialist experiments to free-market absolutism, from conservative retrenchment to progressive overreach. The pendulum never stops.

This is not a flaw in our systems but a feature of human nature itself. We tire easily. We forget quickly. We grow impatient with steady progress and elect the outrageous, hoping their very audacity will deliver what careful governance could not. When one side fails, we turn to the other and then to the extreme. The cycle continues, but the fundamental problems remain.

Why does this pattern persist? Because we place our ultimate trust in man and machine and in political parties, ideologies, technologies, and charismatic figures. Yet human beings, no matter how brilliant, remain fallible. Political systems, no matter how ingenious, cannot account for human weakness. Even our most sophisticated machines operate within the limitations of their creators. They all disappoint because they were never meant to be the foundation of our hope.

God does not disappoint. Unlike human leaders who promise the moon and deliver dust, unlike systems that crumble under their own contradictions, the Divine remains constant, just, and true. This is why the Quran establishes a radical principle: leadership is not about popularity, charisma, or even ideological purity. It is about competence and righteousness.

Allah commands in Surah An-Nisa: "Allah commands you to make over the trusts to those best fitted to discharge them." (4:59) This verse cuts through all our political theater. Leadership is a trust—amanah—and it must be entrusted to those with the capacity and character to fulfill it. Not the loudest voice. Not the most entertaining candidate. Not the person who tells us what we want to hear. But those best fitted to serve.

What makes someone best fitted? The Quran answers in Surah Al-Hajj: "Those who, if We establish them in the earth, will observe Prayer and pay the Zakat and enjoin good and forbid evil." (22:42) True leaders maintain their connection to God through prayer, demonstrate social responsibility through charity, promote virtue, and resist corruption. They fear God more than opinion polls, seek divine approval more than electoral victory, and measure success by justice rather than power.

We need leaders who are God-fearing, not because religion should dictate policy, but because the fear of God instills humility, accountability, and moral courage. A leader who believes they will answer to the Divine thinks twice before abusing power, cutting corners, or sacrificing principle for expediency. They work hard not for legacy but for responsibility. They say and do what is right even when it costs them politically.

The injunction is clear: elect competent leaders of good character. Stop chasing empty promises and revolutionary rhetoric. Stop settling for the lesser evil. Demand those who will observe their duties to both heaven and earth, who will work diligently, speak truthfully, and govern justly. Only then can we break the cycle.

Until we learn this lesson, until we stop placing our faith in man and machine alone and start selecting leaders according to divine standards, we will continue our exhausting journey around the same mountain. The experiments will fail. The disappointments will mount. And we will wonder why nothing ever truly changes.

The answer has been with us for over fourteen centuries. We simply need to apply it.